RIR Resource Allocation Data Inconsistencies

Updated: 08/09/2008 06:01
Full Report APNIC ARIN RIPE LACNIC AFRINIC
AFRINIC Report

This report examines the consistency of data published by afrinic, comparing the stats reports with other reports describing allocations. If the data sets were fully consistent the report would be empty.
This is a report of the various inconsistencies noted in the reports published by AFRINIC. The underlying assumption in these reports is that AFRINIC stats files contain a complete record of all allocated numbers, and that all other reports (including WHOIS databases, issued and latest files) should refer to number ranges described in the stats files. It is also assumed that the stats files do not overlap, and that a whois entry published by each RIR refers to allocated numbers described in that RIRs stats file.
Reasons:
Not in Stats: the entry exists in the named RIR file, but no corresponding entry can be located in the stats file.
Extends Stats: the entry is an aggregate of one or more entries in the RIR stats file, but also encompasses space not recorded in the stats file.
Stats Overlap: the entry exists in the data records of two (or more) RIR data files
Data Overlap: the entry exists in the database data records of an RIR's database report, and in the registry report stats file in another RIR at the same time
IANA Reserved Block: the entry encompasses space that the IANA registry describes as reserved.
Data-Type Registry File         Reason                 Entry

IPv4      afrinic  stats        Stats Overlap          afrinic|DZ|ipv4|192.52.232.0|256|20070920|assigned 192.52.232.0/24 (afrinic.stats) 192.52.232.0/24 (ripe.stats)
                   stats        Stats Overlap          afrinic|GH|ipv4|193.194.128.0|256|20070920|assigned 193.194.128.0/24 (afrinic.stats) 193.194.128.0/19 (ripe.stats)
                   stats        Stats Overlap          afrinic|EG|ipv4|193.227.128.0|256|20070920|assigned 193.227.128.0/24 (afrinic.stats) 193.224.0.0/11 (ripe.stats)
                   stats        Stats Overlap          afrinic|KE|ipv4|194.9.64.0|512|20070920|assigned 194.9.64.0/23 (afrinic.stats) 194.8.0.0/14 (ripe.stats)
                   stats        Stats Overlap          afrinic|KE|ipv4|194.9.82.0|512|20080312|assigned 194.9.82.0/23 (afrinic.stats) 194.8.0.0/14 (ripe.stats)
                   stats        Stats Overlap          afrinic|EG|ipv4|195.234.185.0|256|20070920|assigned 195.234.185.0/24 (afrinic.stats) 195.234.176.0/20 (ripe.stats)
                   stats        Stats Overlap          afrinic|EG|ipv4|195.234.252.0|1024|20070921|assigned 195.234.252.0/22 (afrinic.stats) 195.234.192.0/18 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Not in Stats           netname: ESVNET2 inetnum: 196.13.206.0 - 196.13.206.255 196.13.206.0/24 
                   afrinic.db   Not in Stats           netname: SIOTEL-PH inetnum: 217.78.64.0 - 217.78.66.63 217.78.64.0/23 
                   afrinic.db   Not in Stats           netname: SIOTEL-PH inetnum: 217.78.64.0 - 217.78.66.63 217.78.66.0/26 
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: TE-Data inetnum: 163.121.0.0 - 163.121.255.255 163.121.0.0/16 163.121.0.0/16 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-ITI-1 inetnum: 163.121.12.0 - 163.121.13.255 163.121.12.0/23 163.121.12.0/23 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-ACCESS-1 inetnum: 163.121.32.0 - 163.121.33.255 163.121.32.0/23 163.121.32.0/23 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-OMEGA-1 inetnum: 163.121.36.0 - 163.121.36.255 163.121.36.0/24 163.121.36.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-DATUM-3 inetnum: 163.121.38.0 - 163.121.38.255 163.121.38.0/24 163.121.38.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-GLOBALNET-1 inetnum: 163.121.39.0 - 163.121.39.255 163.121.39.0/24 163.121.39.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-MENANET-1 inetnum: 163.121.42.0 - 163.121.42.255 163.121.42.0/24 163.121.42.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-MENANET-2 inetnum: 163.121.44.0 - 163.121.44.255 163.121.44.0/24 163.121.44.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-ICL-1 inetnum: 163.121.48.0 - 163.121.48.255 163.121.48.0/24 163.121.48.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-WAYOUT-1 inetnum: 163.121.58.0 - 163.121.58.255 163.121.58.0/24 163.121.58.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-CONTACT-1 inetnum: 163.121.62.0 - 163.121.62.255 163.121.62.0/24 163.121.62.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-CNS-1 inetnum: 163.121.70.0 - 163.121.70.255 163.121.70.0/24 163.121.70.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-ASC inetnum: 163.121.71.0 - 163.121.71.255 163.121.71.0/24 163.121.71.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-BOHIARA-1 inetnum: 163.121.76.0 - 163.121.76.255 163.121.76.0/24 163.121.76.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-CNS-2 inetnum: 163.121.92.0 - 163.121.92.255 163.121.92.0/24 163.121.92.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-TECMINA-2 inetnum: 163.121.96.0 - 163.121.96.255 163.121.96.0/24 163.121.96.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-FUTURE-1 inetnum: 163.121.98.0 - 163.121.98.255 163.121.98.0/24 163.121.98.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-ASWANET-1 inetnum: 163.121.100.0 - 163.121.100.255 163.121.100.0/24 163.121.100.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-TECMINA-4 inetnum: 163.121.102.0 - 163.121.102.255 163.121.102.0/24 163.121.102.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-BEC-1 inetnum: 163.121.105.64 - 163.121.105.127 163.121.105.64/26 163.121.105.64/26 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-ACCESS-2 inetnum: 163.121.106.0 - 163.121.106.255 163.121.106.0/24 163.121.106.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-ACCESS-3 inetnum: 163.121.109.0 - 163.121.109.255 163.121.109.0/24 163.121.109.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-SCC-1 inetnum: 163.121.110.0 - 163.121.110.255 163.121.110.0/24 163.121.110.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-COMPUNET-1 inetnum: 163.121.111.0 - 163.121.111.255 163.121.111.0/24 163.121.111.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-BEC-2 inetnum: 163.121.112.0 - 163.121.112.255 163.121.112.0/24 163.121.112.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-RAINBOWNET-1 inetnum: 163.121.113.0 - 163.121.113.255 163.121.113.0/24 163.121.113.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-BEC-3 inetnum: 163.121.115.0 - 163.121.115.255 163.121.115.0/24 163.121.115.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-FUTURE-2 inetnum: 163.121.126.0 - 163.121.126.255 163.121.126.0/24 163.121.126.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-COMMNET-1 inetnum: 163.121.128.0 - 163.121.128.255 163.121.128.0/24 163.121.128.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: TE-DATA-Network inetnum: 163.121.128.0 - 163.121.255.255 163.121.128.0/17 163.121.128.0/17 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-TECMINA-1 inetnum: 163.121.130.0 - 163.121.130.255 163.121.130.0/24 163.121.130.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-INFINITY-1 inetnum: 163.121.131.0 - 163.121.135.255 163.121.131.0/24 163.121.131.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-INFINITY-1 inetnum: 163.121.131.0 - 163.121.135.255 163.121.132.0/22 163.121.132.0/22 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-EIS-2 inetnum: 163.121.136.0 - 163.121.137.255 163.121.136.0/23 163.121.136.0/23 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-TECMINA-5 inetnum: 163.121.138.0 - 163.121.138.255 163.121.138.0/24 163.121.138.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-WAYOUT-2 inetnum: 163.121.139.0 - 163.121.143.255 163.121.139.0/24 163.121.139.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-WAYOUT-2 inetnum: 163.121.139.0 - 163.121.143.255 163.121.140.0/22 163.121.140.0/22 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-PACC-1 inetnum: 163.121.145.0 - 163.121.145.255 163.121.145.0/24 163.121.145.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-MENANET-3 inetnum: 163.121.149.0 - 163.121.149.255 163.121.149.0/24 163.121.149.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-ELARIS-1 inetnum: 163.121.150.0 - 163.121.150.255 163.121.150.0/24 163.121.150.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-INTOUCH-1 inetnum: 163.121.156.0 - 163.121.161.255 163.121.156.0/22 163.121.156.0/22 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-INTOUCH-1 inetnum: 163.121.156.0 - 163.121.161.255 163.121.160.0/23 163.121.160.0/23 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-SOFICOM-1 inetnum: 163.121.163.0 - 163.121.167.255 163.121.163.0/24 163.121.163.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-SOFICOM-1 inetnum: 163.121.163.0 - 163.121.167.255 163.121.164.0/22 163.121.164.0/22 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-FUTURE-3 inetnum: 163.121.168.0 - 163.121.168.255 163.121.168.0/24 163.121.168.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-ATT-1 inetnum: 163.121.169.0 - 163.121.173.255 163.121.169.0/24 163.121.169.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-ATT-1 inetnum: 163.121.169.0 - 163.121.173.255 163.121.170.0/23 163.121.170.0/23 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-ATT-1 inetnum: 163.121.169.0 - 163.121.173.255 163.121.172.0/23 163.121.172.0/23 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-EIS-1 inetnum: 163.121.181.0 - 163.121.185.255 163.121.181.0/24 163.121.181.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-EIS-1 inetnum: 163.121.181.0 - 163.121.185.255 163.121.182.0/23 163.121.182.0/23 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-EIS-1 inetnum: 163.121.181.0 - 163.121.185.255 163.121.184.0/23 163.121.184.0/23 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-STARNET-1 inetnum: 163.121.187.0 - 163.121.191.255 163.121.187.0/24 163.121.187.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-STARNET-1 inetnum: 163.121.187.0 - 163.121.191.255 163.121.188.0/22 163.121.188.0/22 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-DATUM-1 inetnum: 163.121.193.0 - 163.121.196.255 163.121.193.0/24 163.121.193.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-DATUM-1 inetnum: 163.121.193.0 - 163.121.196.255 163.121.194.0/23 163.121.194.0/23 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-DATUM-1 inetnum: 163.121.193.0 - 163.121.196.255 163.121.196.0/24 163.121.196.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-MENANET-4 inetnum: 163.121.197.0 - 163.121.197.255 163.121.197.0/24 163.121.197.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-ALEXNET-1 inetnum: 163.121.211.0 - 163.121.215.255 163.121.211.0/24 163.121.211.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-ALEXNET-1 inetnum: 163.121.211.0 - 163.121.215.255 163.121.212.0/22 163.121.212.0/22 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-ECOM-1 inetnum: 163.121.218.0 - 163.121.218.255 163.121.218.0/24 163.121.218.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-MENANET-5 inetnum: 163.121.223.0 - 163.121.223.255 163.121.223.0/24 163.121.223.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-ECOM-2 inetnum: 163.121.225.0 - 163.121.225.255 163.121.225.0/24 163.121.225.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-DATUM-2 inetnum: 163.121.227.0 - 163.121.227.255 163.121.227.0/24 163.121.227.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-TECMINA-3 inetnum: 163.121.238.0 - 163.121.238.255 163.121.238.0/24 163.121.238.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-INTOUCH-2 inetnum: 163.121.244.0 - 163.121.245.255 163.121.244.0/23 163.121.244.0/23 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-SOFICOM-2 inetnum: 163.121.246.0 - 163.121.247.255 163.121.246.0/23 163.121.246.0/23 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EG-ETS-1 inetnum: 163.121.248.0 - 163.121.248.255 163.121.248.0/24 163.121.248.0/24 (afrinic.db) 163.121.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: AFRIQNET inetnum: 165.231.0.0 - 165.231.255.255 165.231.0.0/16 165.231.0.0/16 (afrinic.db) 165.231.0.0/16 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: CERIST-CNUCE inetnum: 192.52.232.0 - 192.52.232.255 192.52.232.0/24 192.52.232.0/24 (afrinic.db) 192.52.232.0/24 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: IBSNET inetnum: 193.194.128.0 - 193.194.128.255 193.194.128.0/24 193.194.128.0/24 (afrinic.db) 193.194.128.0/19 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: ENSTINET inetnum: 193.227.128.0 - 193.227.128.255 193.227.128.0/24 193.227.128.0/24 (afrinic.db) 193.224.0.0/11 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: KENYA-AIRWAYs-KE inetnum: 194.9.64.0 - 194.9.65.255 194.9.64.0/23 194.9.64.0/23 (afrinic.db) 194.8.0.0/14 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: AFOL-KE inetnum: 194.9.82.0 - 194.9.83.255 194.9.82.0/23 194.9.82.0/23 (afrinic.db) 194.8.0.0/14 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EGNETS-2 inetnum: 195.234.185.0 - 195.234.185.255 195.234.185.0/24 195.234.185.0/24 (afrinic.db) 195.234.176.0/20 (ripe.stats)
                   afrinic.db   Data Overlap           netname: EGNETS-2 inetnum: 195.234.252.0 - 195.234.255.255 195.234.252.0/22 195.234.252.0/22 (afrinic.db) 195.234.192.0/18 (ripe.stats)

AS        afrinic  stats        Stats Overlap          afrinic|EG|asn|2561|1|20070920|allocated 2561 (afrinic.stats) 2561 (ripe.stats)
                   stats        Stats Overlap          afrinic|EG|asn|6127|1|20070920|allocated 6127 (afrinic.stats) 6127 (ripe.stats)
                   stats        Stats Overlap          afrinic|KE|asn|16907|1|20070927|allocated 16907 (afrinic.stats) 16907 (ripe.stats)
                   stats        Stats Overlap          afrinic|KE|asn|19676|1|20070920|allocated 19676 (afrinic.stats) 19676 (ripe.stats)
                   stats        Stats Overlap          afrinic|ZA|asn|25726|1|20020426|allocated 25726 (afrinic.stats) 25726 (ripe.stats)

IPv4      afrinic  stats        Stats Overlap          afrinic|DZ|ipv4|192.52.232.0|256|20070920|assigned 192.52.232.0/24 (afrinic.stats) 192.52.232.0/24 (ripe.stats)
                   stats        Stats Overlap          afrinic|GH|ipv4|193.194.128.0|256|20070920|assigned 193.194.128.0/24 (afrinic.stats) 193.194.128.0/24 (ripe.stats)
                   stats        Stats Overlap          afrinic|EG|ipv4|193.227.128.0|256|20070920|assigned 193.227.128.0/24 (afrinic.stats) 193.227.128.0/24 (ripe.stats)
                   stats        Stats Overlap          afrinic|KE|ipv4|194.9.64.0|512|20070920|assigned 194.9.64.0/23 (afrinic.stats) 194.9.64.0/23 (ripe.stats)
                   stats        Stats Overlap          afrinic|KE|ipv4|194.9.82.0|512|20080312|assigned 194.9.82.0/23 (afrinic.stats) 194.9.82.0/23 (ripe.stats)
                   stats        Stats Overlap          afrinic|EG|ipv4|195.234.185.0|256|20070920|assigned 195.234.185.0/24 (afrinic.stats) 195.234.185.0/24 (ripe.stats)
                   stats        Stats Overlap          afrinic|EG|ipv4|195.234.252.0|1024|20070921|assigned 195.234.252.0/22 (afrinic.stats) 195.234.252.0/22 (ripe.stats)